Home › Optics & camera tech

Mechanical vs electronic shutter

7 min read · Updated

A mechanical shutter uses physical curtains to start and end the exposure. An electronic shutter reads the sensor line by line instead, so it is silent and vibration-free but can skew fast motion, cause banding under artificial light and limit flash use. Many cameras also offer an electronic first curtain as a middle option.

Mechanical vs electronic shutter
Image: Richmilliron, CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

In short

  • Mechanical focal-plane shutters use two moving curtains; very short speeds are a moving slit.
  • Electronic shutters read the sensor row by row; slow readout causes rolling-shutter skew.
  • Flash needs the whole sensor uncovered at once, which sets the flash sync speed.
  • Flickering lights can cause bands with fast shutter speeds, especially with an electronic shutter.

Mechanical focal-plane shutters

Most interchangeable-lens cameras have a focal-plane shutter just in front of the sensor. A first curtain opens to start the exposure and a second curtain follows to end it.

At short shutter speeds, the second curtain starts moving before the first has finished, so the sensor is exposed through a travelling slit. Each part of the frame still gets the right exposure time, but not all at the same moment. Mechanical curtains travel fast, often in a few milliseconds, so the skew is small.

Electronic shutters and rolling shutter

An electronic shutter has no moving parts. The sensor is reset and read out row by row, and the time between reset and readout is the exposure. It is silent, causes no vibration and allows very short speeds and fast bursts.

Reading every row takes time. If the readout takes, for example, around 1/30 s (approximate, varies widely), a moving subject or a fast pan is captured at different moments from top to bottom. Vertical lines lean, propellers bend and golf clubs curve. This is rolling-shutter distortion. Faster stacked sensors shorten the readout and reduce it.

Electronic first curtain

Many cameras offer a hybrid: the exposure starts electronically and a mechanical curtain ends it. This removes the shock of the first curtain, a common cause of slight blur at moderate speeds on a tripod.

At very short speeds and wide apertures, it can sometimes produce uneven exposure or odd bokeh shapes, so a full mechanical shutter is safer there.

Flash sync

A flash burst is very short, often under a thousandth of a second. For it to light the whole frame, the sensor must be fully uncovered at that moment. The fastest speed where that happens is the flash sync speed, often around 1/160–1/250 s with focal-plane shutters (approximate).

Faster than that, part of the frame is covered and you see a dark band. High-speed sync gets around this by pulsing the flash many times, at a cost in power. Leaf shutters, built into some lenses and compact cameras, open from the centre and sync at almost any speed.

With an electronic shutter, the slow readout means flash is often unavailable or limited to much slower speeds. Global-shutter sensors, which read every pixel at once, avoid both skew and this limit.

Banding and flicker

Many LED and fluorescent lights flicker at twice the mains frequency, 100 times a second on 50 Hz grids and 120 times on 60 Hz grids. At short shutter speeds, different rows catch the light at different brightness, so you see horizontal bands.

Electronic shutters show this more because their readout is slower. Fixes include using a shutter speed that matches the flicker, such as 1/50 or 1/100 s on 50 Hz and 1/60 or 1/120 s on 60 Hz, switching to the mechanical shutter, or turning on the camera's anti-flicker feature if it has one.

Which shutter to use

Use the electronic shutter for silence at ceremonies and wildlife, to avoid vibration with long lenses and macro, and for very fast bursts of slow-moving subjects.

Use the mechanical shutter for flash, fast-moving subjects or pans if your sensor reads out slowly, and under flickering artificial light. Silent shooting saves curtain wear, though modern mechanical shutters are rated for many tens of thousands of actuations or more.

Frequently asked questions

Why do my photos have bands indoors?

The lights are probably flickering. Try a shutter speed of 1/50 or 1/100 s on 50 Hz mains, 1/60 or 1/120 s on 60 Hz, or switch to the mechanical shutter.

Can I use flash with the electronic shutter?

Often not, or only at slow speeds, because the sensor takes too long to read out. Check your camera's manual.

Does the electronic shutter save the camera?

It avoids wear on the shutter curtains, which have a limited life, but most mechanical shutters last for many years of normal use.

What is a global shutter?

A sensor that captures all pixels at the same instant. It removes rolling-shutter skew and can sync flash at very high speeds.

Sources

Keep reading